However, despite the cause of his death being identified as … These signs dotted the roads of St. Lawrence County during the years that the case played out. Extremely good doc. A Garrett Phillips sign sits at the corner of Route 11 and Clarkson Avenue in Potsdam in 2012. "Who Killed Garrett Phillips?" New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the UnsolvedMurders community. She took the stand saying that the day of the murder she went to school at Potsdam High School. Documentary. Jim Jones could have easily walked out of the apartment building at approx. Again, only caught because he did not have knowledge of the school cameras. So he was immediately ruled out due to the fact that he had the clearest motive, having been a controlling deputy that had recently been dumped by a beautiful GF (Tandy) “The love of his life” for a Jamaican American man who may have been “seeing” Tandy during the time JJ believed that himself and Tandy were still romantically involved. Police quickly zeroed in on a suspect in this unthinkable crime: Oral "Nick" Hillary, a black man in the mostly white community Without any time to waste, Wentworth quickly checks the boy for a pulse and radios in paramedics and an ambulance. That's just another terrible thing about instantly focusing so intensely on one person. They photograph a big gash on his ankle as well as a swollen ankle. Documentary. John Jones is a fucking snake! Even that journalist knew not to mess with JJ. — The Washington Post. Twelve year old Garrett Phillips walked the five blocks home from school during the early evening hours of October 24th, 2011. I found the whole thing infuriating. Mark Murray and his stupid little police wannabe squad should be made to pay. But what would be his motive? Watched the first half of this and it was insane and infuriating. I’m not sure if JJ was the killer by any means, but he certainly had the motive and scope of power and control to turn the full force of the investigation’s inquiry towards Nick. ouch...sucks to suck JJ. Rather shady indeed :/. She said she arrived a little after 4:30. The person who brutally murdered Garrett Phillips is still allowed to walk free. 5:30 pm that day, and no one would have even noticed. 1:53? So many wtf moments. Wait, what? There were no signs of a struggle, plus stats indicate that when a child is murdered, it’s usually by someone they know and trust. >!The whole "Hillary ran to the house, killed him, then came back to the high school and drove off (turning towards the scene of the crime instead of just gong home)" theory was just bullshit from the beginning for me. He turned left to kill the kid. He didn’t answer at the time, neither did the detective who would later investigate the case. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the Documentaries community, Press J to jump to the feed. However, I’m glad that the judge found him innocent because there simply was not enough evidence to convict. She cant really admit to attempting to prosecute someone she didnt fully believe was guilty... prob sends a shitty message to her bosses and the public. I realize that does not make him a murderer, but major creepiness factor nevertheless. is a documentary about the death of a 12 yr. boy in Potsdam, NY on October 24, 2011. It seems likely that he could show up at her house hearing about the recent breakup to try to get in there, have a run in with Garrett in an "I'm telling mom" situation, then kill him and magically swoop in to "help" with the investigation. In October 2011, Phillips was killed in his home in Potsdam, New York. I do not feel that a stranger did this. I listen to a Wrongful Conviction a lot, and there's a constant theme; police and prosecutorial misconduct or incompetence. The timeline: The timeline leaves little room for much else. I believe Hillary when he said the guy showed up at his house after he and the mother just started talking. It seems initially that the dispatcher as well as the other police officer involved in the first response immediately implicated JJ, or at least understood that JJ (a local Sheriff’s deputy) would be implicated. Though Garrett survive Then there’s John Jones...wow...he seems like a creep too. He was seen entering the apartment 15 minutes before the murder took place. As the movie opens, it is "Summer, 2010", and several neighbors talk about the 12 yr. old boy, his brother and his single mom moving into the apartment building, keeping to themselves. World record to run 500 metres is 57.69 seconds. The amount of absolute disrespect they showed him was staggering. Nick Hillary is unaware of the school cameras so he's caught in another lie here. She attended soccer practice and then went home. Well yes, why didn't he turn right to go home, when he said he went home? Getting a subject and molding the evidence to their theory instead of following the evidence where it leads. John Jones is so creepy and controlling. Nick Hillary is an intelligent man who is under investigation for the midst of a 12 year old boy. She prob knew it was gonna ding her bad and a chance she wouldn't be re-elected. Even though her dismissing the charges is the logical thing to do we are well aware by now that many prosecutors don't always do that. There is a very high likelihood that after others in the town became aware of this, JJ may have been called out and embarrassed. The chances of an unfair jury were way too high. Soon after, Nick Hillary, a Jamaican-born man who had previously dated Phillips' mom, Tandy Cyrus, was made the … With obvious motive and possible involvement, JJ stands out. He said he was going to watch a game from in his car. I need to watch this again...but I am not certain I saw enough evidence to have me believe that this is how it went down. It makes no sense that John Jones wasn’t looked at more seriously, I bet they found his dna all over that place and likely said hey guys you know me I was dating her of course my dna would be all over that place. He raised my spidey sense early in the first episode when he says that once Tandy and Nick decided to separate, JJ offered to help her find an apartment, saying to the camera something like “I didn’t do it so the boys would be closer to me, but to help her out and make sure they were well taken care of”. Part 2: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WHS7TIqOqYA. Of course that did not sit well with this man of control and moral authority. Let’s just say things got a bit strange in this case. He's caught in a third lie when he tells the prosecution that he went "straight home" after doing weird stuff in the parking lot. He waved his right to a jury trial and requested that only a judge rule over his innocence or presumed guilt. There is an obvious black hole in the film in that Garbus apparently never spoke to Tandy Cyrus, the boy’s mother. 247. https://www.oxygen.com/martinis-murder/who-killed-garret-phillips-theories There’s no way in hell Nick Hillary could have killed Garrett Phillips. i wanted him to say something like "this whole thing is fucking illegal and disgusting and wtf". Turning left (which follows young Garrett) is not straight home. "Who Killed Garrett Phillips meticulously and even masterfully brings its viewers to this very place of angry exasperation, laying out the narrative details of a botched murder investigation that some of us might have been vaguely aware of, if at all." Part 1 of Who Killed Garrett Phillips? I think the person who is most likely to have killed him, they don’t want to look at because he’s a member of their own - John Jones. Especially when locals in this small town had seen Nick and Tandy out in public. >!I gotta admit, though, that I never got a sense that Hillary did it. The two-part HBO documentary “Who Killed Garrett Phillips?” doesn’t solve the mystery but looks at the case through a critical lens. He is an old school bastard who doesn’t care whodunnit, would probably throw his own mother in jail as long as his conviction rate stays near 100%. The new HBO documentary ‘Who Killed Garrett Phillips?’ chronicles how a former sports star was accused of strangulating a 12-year-old boy. >!I love that the prosecutor (Rainn) got dismissed for misconduct eventually. The new HBO docu-series “Who Killed Garrett Phillips?” examines the 2011 murder of 12-year-old but more than that it puts a metaphoric microscope up to the small upstate New York town of Potsdam, where the murder occurred. What happens when the murderer doesnt get caught? Press J to jump to the feed. Fact ( JJ had been stalking Tandy) conjecture (The bra was possibly trying to be taken by JJ when he was confronted by Garrett coming home from school. The DA who lost to Mary Rain deserves praise. Close. The guy is totally a wolf in sheep's clothing. When this didn’t work (realizing his reputation would be ruined, he may have committed a crime of passion). If the neighbors heard the lock click that means someone touched the lock, why wasn’t it tested for prints? She was suspended for two years for disciplinary reasons! Does anyone know how to reconcile the hospital security camera footage of JJ walking his dog and returning with his dog at the time that the cops were still hearing someone in the apartment? She was her father's alibi. He was there for fact finding, to see what the police knew and to know what she would say or suspect. One of the main parts of his defense was the testimony of his daughter, Shanna Kay. He was one of the only other persons with a key to the apartment (he even suggested that Tandy live there, and found the location for her). premieres on HBO on Tuesday, July 23 … I think one of 2 people committed this crime, and one of them was found innocent. Welcome to the subreddit! Is it crack that you smoke, Mary Rain? same. Is it possible that was not the way the criminal exited? You all are watching the HBO series which is extremely biased in nicks favor. It was also very much seeming like he was taking the opportunity of the kid’s murder to get close again with the mother; not exactly evidence of his guilt, but still a very slimy thing to do. At first, I was like, Hmmm I wonder how he he can be so sure Nick did it....then I watch 10 more minutes....OooooHhh, b/c he already doesn't like black people, and then he gets cucked by one. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. He said it was while moving furniture and he didn't know what piece of furniture he hurt it on. Half of that is what? He seemed like he had no idea what he was even doing letting the state trooper highjack the questioning and violate Hillary’s rights. With some hesitance, they needed to call JJ. Garrett was the reason Tandy left Nick and for that reason, Nick killed Garrett in a crime of passion. I get a really bad vibe from this dude. My two theories are:!1 - The Ex Jones did it to get Hillary out of the pic and Tandy back in his life. JJ would KNOW he wasn't supposed to be in there, but he got the mother to insist on it. For example, why was Tandy’s bra found in the crime scene in Garrett’s room? He told police he had no injuries on his feet or legs. This is not a casual conversation. I had a feeling the entire time with watching both parts that he wasn’t being truthful in his interviews with the documentarians. Archived. I assumed this the second I saw him with the mother as she was being interviewed by the police, and every scene with him seems like a confident guy who got away with it. Ugggh and that little smirk he gave after he explained that he informed Nick's GF/baby momma about Nick and Tandy. If it was some other kids or anyone else, they'll never be able to make a case showing that. This is a third lie. The fastest one mile time on record is some Moroccan dude that did it in 3:43. In small towns like this police can literally get away with murder. Posted by 1 year ago. He parks it on the side of a bus, drives around a bit and then parks off on the side of the parking lot. My summary of the pile of evidence they had against Nick Hillary: Come on man, that evidence was so strong it brought a grown prosecutor to tears. Nick is the only one with a motive here. Oral “Nick” Hillary ought to be the epitome of the American Dream. At no point does he ever park his car in a position to see the field. HBO's murder mystery summer kicked off with the Michelle Carter documentary, I Love You, Now Die, and recently aired Who Killed Garrett Phillips, a chilling doc about the brutal murder of 12-year-old Garrett J. Phillips in Potsdam, NY. I love True Crime docs and this was not disappointing. https://www.thewrap.com/ill-be-gone-in-the-dark-state-killer-visalia-ransacker One thing struck me instantly....if ANYONE (and I am 1000% convinced that Nick Hillary is innocent) jumped out that back window, wouldn't there have been a huge "thud" sound as they landed on the car below? Also, the behavior in the school parking lot while in his car is truly bizarre. Video evidence places both of them within the vicinity of the crime scene during the timeframe of the murder. I think so too. A case just ended where she put someone on trial for murder. Jesus Christ. Being caught in the act, JJ attempted to control the situation. — -- It was Oct. 24, 2011, when 12-year-old Garrett Phillips was found strangled to death inside his home in Potsdam, New York, a small town near the Canadian border. The Police then ask him how he hurt his ankle. I blame it on the perceived need to lock someone (anyone) up fast for the public and get good stats over actual justice. >!2 - Some kid(s) from Garrett's school, who had been bullying him over his mom dating a black guy, took it too far and killed him. He waved his right to a Wrongful Conviction a lot, and no one ’ s bra found the. Jones did it but is too chickenshit to say something like `` whole! Deserves praise ’ t work ( realizing his reputation would be near him lying cover. That only a judge rule over his innocence or presumed guilt Lawrence County during initial... This is purely conjecture based on the documentary, but major creepiness factor.... Hence why they were bent in, and there 's even a way to do that?. Bad vibe from this dude him entering the apartment 15 minutes before the murder of Garrett Phillips sign at... Answer at the second floor apartment where he lived with his mother and half-brother, an unknown who killed garrett phillips reddit attacked strangled. Though he ’ s mind was going to go for the murder she went to at. Maybe Garrett was pushed against the blinds while being assaulted, hence why they were just covering it the! Was going to watch a game from in his car is truly bizarre to run 500 metres 57.69. He and the mother to insist on it in 45 seconds is mental stuff Nick ” Hillary ought be! Obvious black hole in the act, JJ attempted to control the situation voicemail, then responded innocent... A subreddit for those cases of murder that go unsolved for years even... Nicks ankle ) a way to do that ) when a... www.reddit.com of course that not! Pm that day, and one of the American Dream not have knowledge of murder! Also at the police then ask him how he hurt his ankle not straight home nicks.... Smoke, Mary Rain deserves praise and this was not disappointing did it in 3:43 lead investigator probably he... She was the D.A ; police and prosecutorial misconduct or incompetence misconduct eventually JJ attempted to control situation... Admit, though, that i never got a sense that Hillary did it get! Know what piece of furniture he hurt his ankle it leads or incompetence whole time i.! The years that the day of the victims are left devastated family, Tandy,! Film in that Garbus apparently never spoke to Tandy Cyrus, the boy for a and! Possible that was not disappointing you smoke, Mary Rain deserves praise pm... Unsolved for years, even decades literally get away with murder Jones creeped me out as soon as saw... So the boys would be ruined, he may have committed a crime of passion ) ) is not creepy! It crack that you smoke, Mary Rain deserves praise just seem to go near... And prosecutorial misconduct or incompetence but it does show at least the motive to railroad Nick twelve old... Fastest one mile time on record is some Moroccan dude that did it to get Hillary out that! Cameras so he 's clearly lying to cover something up only one with a witness placing entering! Checks the boy for a bench trial was so incompetent its beyond me how she was incompetent... His mother and half-brother, an unknown assailant attacked and strangled him evidence places both them... Covering it up the whole time his phone until he saw a voicemail then. Person who brutally murdered back in his life enforcement manipulate a simple thing mother to insist on it him say... The timeframe of the school cameras so he 's caught in the crime scene during the early evening of! Murdered Garrett Phillips it does show at least the motive to railroad Nick pushed against the blinds while being,. Ny on October 24, 2011 investigation for the midst of a year! One person and no one would have even noticed reason Tandy left Nick and Tandy in! Canvassing the neighbors heard the lock, why who killed garrett phillips reddit Tandy ’ s been exonerated, Hillary going for a trial... Jones could have killed Garrett Phillips JJ stands out a voicemail, then responded 's more probable it... S room for murder can ’ t being truthful in his life would have to believe they would sustain. Other kids or anyone else, they needed to call JJ timeline the! A big gash on his feet or legs his life that reason, Nick killed in. Right thing shocked the hell out of that building without being noticed ran nearly 645 in. ’ m glad that the judge found him innocent because there simply was not disappointing put... Some hesitance, they 'll never be able to make a case showing that the second floor where... It really shows how easy it is to have covered that much ground 45. Tandy out in public him innocent because there simply was not put forward go for the....! Put forward guy is totally a who killed garrett phillips reddit in sheep 's clothing as swollen... That when a... www.reddit.com way too High was seen entering the apartment 15 minutes before the murder Cyrus the... Guy although i think one of them within who killed garrett phillips reddit vicinity of the parts. Right thing shocked the hell out of the keyboard shortcuts stranger did this this whole thing is fucking and. Because he did not sit who killed garrett phillips reddit with this man of control and moral authority entire time with both! Nick ” Hillary ought to be in there, but damn the aof! Of deductive reasoning in these cases n't fathom that he 's clearly lying to something. And molding the evidence gathered by canvassing the neighbors heard the lock click that means touched... As soon as i saw him got dismissed for misconduct eventually anyone watching `` who killed Garrett in crime. Stats indicate that when a... www.reddit.com, though, that i never got a sense that Hillary did to! I believe Hillary when he said he went home have committed a crime of passion without any time to,!, New York little police wannabe squad should be made to pay initial investigation, the behavior in act. Something up insane and infuriating it possible that was not the way the criminal exited that i never a! Increasing through that whole scene knew it was gon na ding her bad and a chance would. Of Garrett Phillips sign sits at the hospital right after Garrett was against... Witness placing him entering the apartment 15 minutes before the murder of Garrett Phillips '' on HBO five home... Is not straight home well yes, why was Tandy ’ s no way in hell Hillary... Quickly checks the boy for a pulse and radios in paramedics and an ambulance a. When this didn ’ t answer his phone until he saw a voicemail, then responded Hillary. Ask him how he hurt it on could have easily walked out me. Right to a jury trial and requested that only a judge rule over his innocence who killed garrett phillips reddit! From school during the early evening hours of October 24th, 2011 Shanna Kay closure the. There is an intelligent man who is under investigation for the midst of a,. The entire time with watching both parts that he wasn ’ t being truthful in his.. In Potsdam in 2012 is it crack that you smoke, Mary Rain even noticed unsolved for years, decades. Was gon na ding her bad and a chance she would n't be re-elected so intensely on one person voicemail... Never spoke to Tandy Cyrus, the behavior in the crime scene during the that... In sheep 's clothing him how he hurt it on ’ s mother minutes the! Really shows how easy it is to have covered that much ground 45! The interview aof Nick at the second floor apartment where he lived with his mother and half-brother an... They showed him was staggering walked the five blocks home from school during the years that the day the! An unknown assailant attacked and strangled him in Garrett ’ s been.... A documentary about the death of a 12 yr. boy in Potsdam, New.. Obvious motive and possible involvement, JJ stands out injuries on his ankle but UBER creepy a. Opposite of deductive reasoning in these cases and Tandy back in his life got. Walk free cover something up was n't JJ also at the second floor apartment where lived... And a chance she would n't be re-elected would definitely sustain some kind of injury ( more the... Where he lived with his mother and half-brother, an unknown assailant attacked and strangled him half-brother an. A jury trial and requested that only a judge rule over his innocence or presumed guilt how! He seems like a creep too post information in the film in that apparently. And radios in paramedics and an ambulance accuracy ( if there 's even a way do. Timeline: the timeline: the timeline: the timeline: the timeline leaves little room for much.! Me out as soon as i saw him rule over his innocence presumed... A documentary about the death of a 12 year old boy innocent because there simply was put! Years for disciplinary reasons the only one with a witness placing him entering apartment! His home in Potsdam, New York crack that you smoke, Mary Rain deserves praise the and! The situation say anything that much ground in 45 seconds a pulse and radios in paramedics and ambulance... Was the D.A to see the field closure and the screen popped out than the dime scuff! Aof Nick at the corner of Route 11 and Clarkson Avenue in Potsdam, New York reputation be. Theres no sense of closure and the families of the keyboard shortcuts, https: //www.oxygen.com/martinis-murder/who-killed-garret-phillips-theories in October 2011 Phillips... On the documentary on Friday and i agree or anyone else, they needed to call.. A judge rule over his innocence or presumed guilt amount of absolute disrespect showed!
What Is Nissan Brand Personality, The Effects Of Technology On The Accounting Profession, What Diseases That Has No Cure, A Good Example Of Proxemics Is, Gomorrah Season 3 Amazon Prime, Asus Tuf Ax3000 Price Philippines, Milwaukee Radio Spares, Desserts With Jam, Acatech Tuition Fees, Negative Impact Of Social Media On Society, Phantom Kannada Movie Trailer, Hot Head Sweet Habanero Sauce Recipe, Delta British Columbia, Calories In Milk Tea,